Shu Ha Ri

    Writing is thinking; AI writing is not thinking

    Two articles about the importance of writing it down for yourself.

    The first article reinforces the claim of Leslie Lamport, the American computer scientist:

    If you think without writing, you only think you’re thinking.
    — Leslie Lamport

    The second article gives clear examples of how human thought degrades when exposed to automation.


    I’m the author of Shu Ha Ri: The Japanese Way of Learning, for Artists and Fighters, available now.

    And if you found this article interesting you might like to sign up to the Writing Slowly weekly email digest. Thanks for reading.

    Why are some teachings a 'secret'?

    Shigehiko Toyama’s book Shiko No Seirigaku (1983), published in English as The Art of Organising Thoughts (Penguin, 2026), includes a comment on the ‘secret teachings’ of traditional Japanese schools of learning:

    “Secret teachings are secret for a reason. You need to do your best to hide them from even your most beloved student. Eventually the student will give up on trying to be taught the secret and start to wonder how they can instead steal it from their master.” (p.14)

    The key insight here is that merely learning everything the master knows isn’t enough. The student who hangs forever on their teacher’s every word will remain forever a student. They will always require someone to show them what there is to learn. But there is a crucial threshold to be crossed, where the student works out how to steal the knowledge they seek — in other words, to find it for themselves, despite the resistence. As Toyama says:

    “The student who has committed to stealing that which their master does not wish to freely impart discovers that they have developed the ability to acquire new pieces of information and knowledge under their own steam.”

    This way of thinking about the value of ’secret teachings’ puts a new spin on the understanding of anthropologist David Graeber about the authority of the teacher.

    “What he liked, he said, was self-subverting authority, authority which undermines its own basis. He gave the example of a teacher: A teacher knows something useful to their student, and so they have a natural authority; but if they do their job well, at the end of the process the student knows what the teacher knows, and their authority is spent. The hierarchy is flattened, and no further unequal power can accrue. The student is changed, and so is the world.”
    — James Bridle, ‘Benchma(r)king’. Emergence.

    Toyama’s insight is that the end of a student’s learning process is not simply to know what the teacher knows, as though there was a bucket of knowledge to be poured from the head of the teacher to fill up the head of the student. No, the end of a student’s learning is to know how the teacher knows, to know how to steal the ’secret’ knowledge the world hides but doesn’t ultimately withhold from a determined seeker. It’s this effectual desire to learn that propels the learner from the Shu stage of learning (imitation or emulation), through the Ha stage (assimilation or adaptation), and into the Ri stage (transcendence). This is why learning how to learn is the most important aspect of the learning journey.

    I’m the author of Shu Ha Ri: The Japanese Way of Learning, for Artists and Fighters, available now.

    And if you found this article interesting you might like to sign up to the Writing Slowly weekly email digest. You’ll receive all the week’s posts in that handy email format you know and love.

    I really like writing while on a train journey, and this article about a crazy train trip project in Japan is inspiring. Japan Today.

    #WritingLife #Japan #productivity

    There is something you find interesting

    💬 “Why do you never find anything written about that idiosyncratic thought you advert to, about your fascination with something no one else understands? Because it is up to you. There is something you find interesting, for a reason hard to explain. It is hard to explain because you have never read it on any page; there you begin. You were made and set here to give voice to this, your own astonishment.” – Annie Dillard, ‘Write Till You Drop’. New York Times, 28 May, 1989.

    I’ve mentioned Annie Dillard previously, and in fact have quoted another section from this very article.

    Anyway, Dillard put her finger on the reason I wrote my little book, Shu Ha Ri, the Japanese Way of Learning. Not that no one else understood the concept (I mean, almost everyone in Japan probably understands it better than me), but that I’d never seen a satisfying book-length treatment. So that’s where I began, by expressing my own fascination.

    Why I wrote the book on Shuhari and what’s in it for you

    The consolations of literature

    On a train trip West from Tokyo on the Chuo line you pass by the Northern slopes of Mount Fuji, but from the angles offered it’s hard to see the summit. This was doubly the case when we did it on the way to the Nagano prefecture because that early September day was rainy and misty.

    I pointed my phone’s camera in the vague direction of the peak but I was guessing and it wasn’t worth pressing the shutter. There was nothing to see. Mount Fuji’s looming presence expressed itself as an absence beyond viewing.

    In a charity store yesterday I picked up the Penguin Classics edition of Matsuo Bashō’s The Narrow Road to the Deep North. This contains a couple of additional accounts of the poet’s famous travels, including ‘The Records of a Weather-exposed Skeleton’, in which Bashō writes:

    💬 “I crossed the barrier-gate of Hakone on a rainy day. All the mountains were deeply buried behind the clouds.

    In a way

    It was fun

    Not to see Mount Fuji

    In foggy rain.”

    Well, sometimes it’s comforting to know you’re not the first to miss out – and to be reminded that missing out might just hold its own subtle pleasure. This perspective might lack credibility unless you recognise that most days, as with Hokusai’s famous 36 Views of Mount Fuji, it’s almost impossible not to see that sacred mountain.

    Auto-generated description: A paperback copy of The Narrow Road to the Deep North and Other Travel Sketches by Matsuo Bashō, part of the Penguin Classics series, is shown with a price sticker and detailed text on the cover.

    “He’s like Jesus with a plow, and we’ve gotta walk beside him with our hands on that plow if we’re going to learn anything from him.”.

    An apprenticeship in writing, with Wendell Berry. | Substack

    I made the twenty photographs that accompany the text of Shu Ha Ri as part of a personal learning process, inspired by David Ulrich’s Zen Camera. I was influenced by Empire of Signs by Roland Bathes. As the author said of that work, “The text does not ‘gloss’ the images, which do not ‘illustrate’ the text.” During the COVID pandemic it was impossible to travel far, but several Japanese-style gardens were within reach. The images included here are of three in particular: Himeji Garden in Adelaide, Edogawa Commemorative Garden in East Gosford, and Auburn Botanic Garden in Sydney.

    Two large stones are placed on finely raked sand with curved patterns in a minimalist Zen garden.

    Learning to tell a bright cow from a dull one

    You might be wondering how anyone can grow from being an advanced learner to becoming an expert. It might seem like an impossible step to climb.

    According to the traditional Japanese approach of Shu Ha Ri, a vital step in the learning process is to so absorb the rules that the student transcends them. The rules and conventions become second nature. But what does that look like in practice?

    Here’s a great example from the world of veterinary medicine, where veterinary students were trained to identify whether an animal is bright (i.e healthy) or dull (i.e. sickening):

    “Eventually, the students get good enough at evaluating bright vs. dull. What’s interesting is that, by then, they’ve lost the rules. What was once effortful and algorithmic is now perceptual and automatic. They can see things you and I do not.” – Oddly-Influenced

    Two Highland cows are grazing on a lush green field near a Scottish loch with trees and hills in the background.

    I’m the author of Shu Ha Ri: The Japanese Way of Learning, for Artists and Fighters, available now.

    And if you found this article interesting you might like to sign up to the Writing Slowly weekly email digest. You’ll receive all the week’s posts in a handy email format which you might prefer. But this site does of course have an RSS feed.

    The heart of the craft: an encounter with the spirit of Shokunin

    “There’s something to be learned from everything. From even the most ordinary, commonplace things, there’s always something you can learn.” – Haruki Murakami, Pinball, 1973.

    I read this quote in the epilogue to Matt Alt’s book, Pure Invention: How Japan Made the Modern World. (London: Constable, 2021).

    It could be a summary of shokunin kishitsu (職人気質), the spirit of traditional Japanese artesanal culture.

    In fact, Jiro Ono the consummate master of sushi, featured in the acclaimed documentary Jiro Dreams of Sushi, and who was still going strong at the age of 100, says something very similar in the movie:

    Read More →

    ”A student’s understanding of particular subjects forms in collaboration with teachers, peers and the daily friction of being one mind among many.” – W. Ian O’Byrne

    A thoughtful article on the messy process that helps kids learn.

Older Posts →